Go Back

Comparing and Selecting Chemical Protective Garments

We're here to help you sort things out.

Permeation matters.

When it comes to chemical protection, permeation is the only test that represents a fabric's true chemical resistance.

That's why DuPont publishes permeation data. In fact, we've published more than 2,400 permeation results for our Tychem® garment fabrics.

Permeation Matters

Permeation is the movement of liquid or gas through a fabric at the molecular level.

Not every manufacturer gives you the full picture.

Not all garment manufacturers publish permeation data. For example, Lakeland Industries only publishes penetration data for its chemical resistant/secondary flame-resistant garment, Pyrolon® CRFR.

They provide no information about how the garment performs in permeation tests.

DuPont, on the other hand, publishes permeation data for our chemical resistant/secondary flame-resistant garment fabric, Tychem® 2000 SFR.

Bottom line?
If chemical protection is your need, permeation is your test. Make sure you know the type of test that was conducted on your garments.

Permeation Data of Fabrics

Lakeland

X

DuPont Data

Check

What's missing?
Lakeland publishes penetration data for its Pyrolon® CRFR garment, but no permeation data.

DuPont knows that you need accurate permeation data to make good garment fabric decisions. That's why we conduct this testing and make it readily available to our users. Our database is the industry's most extensive, with the greatest breadth of permeation data.

Pyrolon Chart

Lakeland. (2018, June 18). Lakeland Pyrolon®CRFR Data Sheet. Retrieved from http://www.lakeland.com

Comparisons can be confusing.

When you're considering how long garments can be worn before chemical breakthrough, it's important to understand the type of permeation testing that has been performed on them.

ASTM F739 specifies that results should be recorded at a normalized breakthrough time (NBT) of 0.1 µg/cm2/min. DuPont tests all Tychem® fabrics using this method. ASTM F739 is the standard test used in North America. Another commonly used permeation test uses an NBT of 1.0 µg/cm2/min., a rate used in Europe per EN ISO 6529.

The ASTM F739 method, the method DuPont sites, is the more stringent and sensitive test for chemical permeation, because it defines breakthrough at a 10x lower threshold.

Competitive Microsite Graph

Bottom line?
When deciding on protective garments, make sure you're comparing fabrics that are tested at the same permeation rate limits.

  • Seek data for the specific chemicals you work with.
  • Look at the permeation test limit method used (1.0 µg/cm2/min or 0.1 µg/cm2/min) in addition to NBT.

Why?
The decision could possibly mean the difference between protection and exposure. Because DuPont uses the more stringent method for all testing, the selection process is easier.

Which certification matters?

There are many standards out there that measure garment performance. CE certification is a measure of performance required by the European Union. The CE marking means that chemical protective clothing meets certain minimum requirements, but it doesn't indicate superior performance versus non-CE certified garments.

Learn more about CE marking.


Bottom line?
Garment protection comes down to understanding the specific hazards your workers face and knowing how their garments will perform against those hazards. DuPont™ SafeSPEC™ can help.

Note: If CE Certification is required by your organization, DuPont offers CE certified apparel as well.

Certification

CE Certification doesn't apply to the U.S. market.

Not everything is what it "seams"

Seams make a big difference in the overall protection a garment provides.

Some competitors may compare performance of a taped or bound seam garment to that of a serged seam garment.

That's not an honest, "apples-to-apples" comparison. Performance comparisons should always be made between garments with similar seam constructions.

DuPont offers garments with different types of seams: serged, bound, and taped. When deciding which garment to purchase, make sure you compare garments with the same type of seams, and select a seam type that meets your hazard needs.

Seams

Different seams offer different levels of protection. It's misleading to make comparisons between garments with different kinds of seams.

Focus on the fabric.

When you're reviewing competitors' claims of how their fabrics perform versus Tyvek®, pay attention to the fabric type.

For example, the fabrics Lakeland and Kimberly-Clark compare to Tyvek® typically are made with either microporous film (MPF) or spunbond-meltblown-spunbond (SMS) fabric—neither of which has the unique properties of Tyvek®.

Engineered using proprietary, flashspun polyethylene technology, garments made with Tyvek® fabric provide many advantages versus the competition, including superior barrier protection after abrasion, durability and comfort.

Fabric Type

Not all "white suits" have the built-in protection of Tyvek®.

Bottom line?
There are many SMS and microporous film-based personal protective equipment (PPE) fabric options, but there's only one Tyvek®.

Performance that speaks for itself.

DuPont is the trusted leader in PPE garment technology for good reason.

Every protective garment we make is the result of years of product development and testing.

We offer a full range of suits that are matched to nearly every on-the-job hazard, from dirt and grit to some of the most toxic compounds on earth.

We don't make confusing comparisons or offer incomplete data. Our test results and garment performance speak for themselves.


Bottom line?
There's no substitute for DuPont protection.

Tyvek Protective Apparel

Get the facts.

Go right to the source with DuPont™ SafeSPEC™. Our online selector tool makes it easy to find dependable, rigorously tested protective garments that meet your hazard needs.

VISIT SAFESPEC™

SafeSPEC